Whats the difference between harry potter and the deathly hallows the book and harry potter and the deathly hallows part 1 the movie. In my opinion this shows at least some sort of admiration or respect towards the power and history of the wand. In the movie deathly hallows part 1 harry doesnt ever disarm malfoy he simply snatches the wand. Written for grindeldore holiday exchange 2019, prompt. Another thing i noticed is in deathly hallows part 2, hermione disarms malfoy in the room of requirement after which harry saves malfoy and never disarms him again. Harry then used the wand to repair his original wand, and interred the elder with dumbledore again. Grindelwald in dh book vs movie minor rant discussion. In the movie, hermione presumably disposed of harrys wand after revealing that his wand was broken, after harry said its done. Harry doesnt pass out and he sees ron grab the sword. So 17 years compared to 19 does put more used to malfoys wand while in the books not only does harry have the phoenix the elder wand is possible to get to in a emergency though in the movies both. I know it is impossible for the movie to wholly follow the book and granted, grindelwald aint a big part of the hp movies anyway, but urgh, just want to share as this particular deviation. House elves are mistreated, but play vital roles vs movie. In harry potter and the deathly hallows, it became apparent.
Profiles of each wand feature stunning new photography of the original props, wand statistics, insights from the cast and crew, and other filmmaking secrets from the warner bros. Times harry potter movies butchered the books screenrant. I absolutely loved everything about the book there was so much more suspense. The filmmakers first designed albus dumbledores wand for its first appearance in the film adaptation of harry potter and the goblet of fire in 2005, years before it was revealed to be the elder wand, or indeed what the elder wand even was, when harry potter and the deathly hallows was published in 2007. That wands more trouble than its worth, said harry. To give back what he borrowed, a harry potter fanfic fanfiction. Even though its not the obsessive kind that dumbledore felt due to it being one of the hallows. Harry potter and lord voldemort duel from harry potter and the deathly hallows part 2 2011 longtime harry potter director david yates understood the weight of the franchises final showdown and stuck with his instincts to.
Switching wands is not the simple task it first appears to be. Rowling is one of the greatest authors of the present day, and shes well known for weaving together complex and sophisticated plots. While i didnt expect to be first in line for the final harry potter movie, at 11 p. When voldemort killed snape towards the end of the book, he believed he now owned the wand, but he still didnt, hence it continually failing to kill harry. They did that with every book when it was made into a movie, though. To give back what he borrowed, a harry potter fanfic. Harry is able to show the audience that he doesnt want the elder wand for selfish reasons and make sure that no one else will use it. Voldemort cast a killing curse on harry using the elder wand. In the books, harry does something much more logical. I was watching the film harry potter and the deathly hallows part 2 in which harry broke the elder wand. Fantastic beasts 2s biggest plot hole is the elder wand. He then returns the elder wand to dumbledores tomb. Harry raised the resurrection stone and the elder wand and stated, i, harry james potter, command you.
Harry potter fans are freaking out over this theory. Dumbledore has a different thought about the creation of these objects. The fate of almost every wizard who has had the elder wand had been a violent death and the wand is taken away from its previous owner. Movie harry was the only rightful owner of the elder wand. Death stepped forward and harry nervously shifted from foot to foot. Whats the difference between harry potter and the deathly hallows the book and harry potter and the deathly hallows part 2 the movie. In the movie, he broke the wand because he didnt want anymore people to steal it for power. Remember that harrys goal was to defeat the dark lord. In the deathly hallows book, harry uses the elder wand to mend his own.
The elder wand started off according to the tale of the three brothers in the tales of beedle the bard, the three brothers suspected to be antioch, cadmus, and ignotus peverell were out travelling the world one day when they came to a treach. Harry replaces the elder wand in dumbledores tomb vs movie. Is this is a mistake in the book or just a blooper in the film. According to legend, whoever united it with the resurrection stone and the cloak of invisibility would be the master of death. Why was the ending of the book different from the ending of the movie in regards to the elder wand. Harry, ron and hermione stand on the remains of the viaduct. Harry potter collectible wand by the noble collection. After defeating voldemort, harry goes to dumbledores office and uses the elder wand repair his broken holly wand. I recently started listen to potterless podcast which you should totally go check out cause it is quite fun and one of the things that came up was the lack of definition to the magical system in the harry. Harry had entered a limbo state, portrayed as kings cross station, from which he could choose to return. From an inuniverse perspective, he was impersonating graves, and so would have had to use gravess wand to maintain his cover.
What is the story behind the elder wand in harry potter. The elder wand from harry potter will be surprisingly important in fantastic beasts 2. Ollivander appears to be familiar with the deathly hallows, while in the book, he doesnt understand what the term means. In the end, he was murdered for his seemingly unbeatable wand. Harry potter and the deathly hallows summary shmoop. Oct 28, 2011 in the book, he returned the elder wand back to its original place. Everything we know about the elder wand wizarding world.
The wand is the most powerful one in the world, of course, and to break it and throw it into the ravine seems wasteful at best. By destroying the elder wand, it will no longer be available for any future wizardswitches that try to use it for evil and power. I am the master of death as i now hold all three deathly hallows. In the wizard fable the tale of the three brothers, the eldest brother was gifted a powerful wand created by death himself. Harry nodded with understanding, stepped forward and with his foot, dragged it through the salt, breaking the summoning circle. Harry takes the elder wand, repairs his own wand, which hermione broke, and then places it back in dumbledores tomb where it belongs.
The elder wand knows no loyalty except to strength. Whether they met death on a lonely roadi think it more likely that the peverell brothers were simply. At the end of deathly hallows part 2, harry simply destroys the elder wand, with no mention made of his old one. Does that mean harry is still the owner of the elder wand. Only a true potterhead will get 2020 on this books and. Death stopped in front of him and harry reached out to give him the elder wand. The elder wand, originally owned by antioch peverell, is one of the three deathly hallows created by death himself, according to the tale of the three brothers. The elder wand is strange and unfamiliar, and harder for albus to accept than hed expected. Top 10 shocking differences between the harry potter. Read elder wand from the story harry potter jokes by kellytt28 kelly with 5,464 reads. Harry potter and the deathly hallows quotes shmoop. The elder wand from harry potter will be surprisingly. Mr ollivanders famous statement the wand chooses the wizard rings just as true for the elder wand as any other.
I was the same age as harry when he first received his hogwarts letter. Nov 15, 2018 the elder wand from harry potter will be surprisingly important in fantastic beasts 2. It was said to be the most powerful wand that had ever existed and was able to perform feats of magic that would normally be. Harry snaps the elder wand in two and throws it over the side. Even he cant take down dumbledore with elder wand and multiple aurors at. The elder wand, the wand of professor dumbledore with ollivanders wand box is a meticulous recreation of the wand prop used in the harry potter film series, crafted with high quality materials.
Harry does not go to the headmasters office after the battle. Still, though, you may notice that the scene is just as awkward on screen as it was in the book. Apr 12, 2011 voldemort gaining the possesion of the elder wand deathly hallows part 1 ending scene hd. On the elder wand being interred with dumbledore, cf. It responds to power it is evident that harry does not even get his hands on the elder wand until the battle of hogwarts after he defeats voldemort. Comparing harry potter and the deathly hallows, part 2, the book and the movie. Only a true potterhead will get 2020 on this books and movies quiz. Harry saw voldemorts green jet meet his own spell, saw the elder wand fly high, dark against the sunrise, spinning across the enchanted ceiling like the head of nagini, spinning through the air toward the master it would not kill, who had come to take full possession of it at last. Harry does not use the elder wand to repair his original wand nor does he consider returning it to dumbledores tomb. Harry snaps the elder wand in half and throws both pieces into a chasm. Mar 28, 2018 in the movie, however, this scene gets demoted to deleted scene status. Harry potter the last owner of the elder wand home.
Assuming harry is never defeated, the wand will be no better than any standard wand a wizard might carry, and in some cases, worse, as seen with hermione not liking bellatrixs wand, or harry feeling like the wand he used in the interim not. There was the faintest trace of longing in his voice as he looked at the elder wand. This post is a comparison of major plot points in the movie and book versions of harry potter and the deathly hallows pt. Remember that harry s goal was to defeat the dark lord. Voldemort gaining the possesion of the elder wand deathly. In the book, he returned the elder wand back to its original place. Harry potter and the deathly hallows part 2 book vs movie add a difference. So, as far as this being a negative change from the bookstraight up not including it at allis kind of up in the air. Nov 06, 2016 harry potter fans are freaking out over a new fan theory which suggests dumbledore wasnt the powerful wizard everyone assumed he was. In the books harry places the wand back to dumbledores grave. When i was 11, i read harry potter and the sorcerers stone for the first time. At the end of the film harry potter and deathly hallows. Yet the movie had grindelwald directly betray and reveal to voldemort that dumbledore was the last owner of the elder wand and the wand was. My answer includes a lot of speculation on the specific.
Aug 03, 2007 uhm, i have read and concluded from book 6 and 7 that harry is the master of the elder wand because harry got malfoys wand in the house but what confuses me is that how did malfoy got the wand from dumbldor when in fact, he just disarmed dumbldors wand which remained to be with dumbldor til voldemort got it in his tomb. Harry potter fans are freaking out over a new fan theory which suggests dumbledore wasnt the powerful wizard everyone assumed he was. The elder wand, variably known as the deathstick, the wand of destiny, the eldruhn wand, and the elhorn wand, is one of the deathly hallows. Harry potter and the deathly hallows book vs the movie. This is the one real moment of undiluted romance we get in. Voldemort gaining the possesion of the elder wand deathly hallows part 1 ending scene hd. The book describes an elaborate conversational battle between harry and voldemort, where harry reveals secrets and insights to voldemort and everyone like snape s true allegiance, elder wand s real owner, etc.
Harry potter and the deathly hallows plays thoughtfully upon the standard harry potter formula that weve all gotten used to over the course of the last six books we begin with a menacing taste of whats to come this time with a glimpse of what voldemort and his death eaters are up to, find ourselves at privet drive at the end of the summer. This is essentially the same meaning as in the book, but simpler for audiences and quicker to show. He waved his hands and the dagger and scythe disappeared. Why did harry potter break the elder wand in the end of. Harry potter and the deathly hallows that was not in the book. Nov 19, 2018 circling back to the 1920s, grindelwald didnt wield the elder wand in fantastic beasts and where to find them.
Yet the movie had grindelwald directly betray and reveal to voldemort that dumbledore was the last owner of the elder wand and the wand was buried with him. The crimes of grindelwald is the elder wand but is there a way to fix it. The elder wand as shown in pottermore is quite different from the screen version in that it was very plain and has two balls on the handle, one larger than the other as they proceed up the shaft. However, in the book he put the wand back inside dumbledores grave. Differences between harry potter and the deathly hallows. I feel that the harry potter film series slightly messed up the final battle. The battle scene in the book is so much better than the movie and at the end of the book harry does use the elder wand at least once he doesnt just break it in half like it shows in the movie. Harry potter and the deathly hallows part 1 book vs movie add a difference. Everything you need to know about the elder wand of harry. Rowling, there are some distinct tendencies in its manner of choosing. Part 2, harry broke the elder wand in two pieces and threw them away. It is incorrect to assume that it is the wand which must be taken, rather the previous owner must be defeated.
Doesnt harry breaking the elder wand make dumbledores. The argument is all to do with the elder wand which. The wand collection is a visual guide to these magical wands, their makers, and the characters who mastered them. In the movie the locket strangles harry into unconsciousness. He tests it on a lamp causing a jet of flames to shoot out. This final book vs movie post is likely to be a little shorter than the others since i did split deathly hallows in half in order to align with the films rather than the books, so there is significantly less chapters to get through, but there is still just as much to talk about since this is the ending of a 7 book series.
Unlike the books, we actually see harry breaking the elder wand in half in the movies. Harry could return to his body despite being hit by the killing curse from the elder wand because voldemort had used harrys blood to regain his full strength in harry potter and the goblet of fire, and because the actual master of the elder wand, draco malfoy, had been defeated by harry making harry the new master of the elder wand. After defeating voldemort, harry snaps the elder wand in half and throws both pieces into a chasm. He stepped forward and looked at deathly hallows before nodding. There are spoilers of major scenes, events and deaths.
145 1448 102 340 447 90 817 614 1213 13 635 1226 928 43 1498 424 1244 270 894 1097 121 1587 435 1511 1589 1318 78 253 850 1331 718 503 1002 578 494 18 965 1477 49 183 916 768 1327